If you follow the news with even a passing interest, you've almost certainly heard about the recent controversy surrounding famed
New York Times columnist
Maureen Dowd. It seems that Dowd, who is known for her scathing political commentaries, plagiarized nearly an entire paragraph from the popular blog
Talking Points Memo (TPM) in her latest column. TPM is written by
Josh Marshall.
Here are the two paragraphs, and you can instantly see the similarities.
Dowd's paragraph in the Times:
More and more the timeline is raising the question of why, if the torture was to prevent terrorist attacks, it seemed to happen mainly during the period when the Bush crowd was looking for what was essentially political information to justify the invasion of Iraq. Marshall's paragraph in his TPM blog:
More and more the timeline is raising the question of why, if the torture was to prevent terrorist attacks, it seemed to happen mainly during the period when we were looking for what was essentially political information to justify the invasion of Iraq. Dowd contends that the copied words were an inadvertent, honest mistake, and you can decide whether or not she is being truthful. It's not my goal with this post to determine her guilt or innocence.
The bigger issue for this post is pointing out the tremendous lesson to be learned or reaffirmed from this case:
as a lawyer doing his or her own marketing or perhaps as a lawyer who has hired a person to handle your marketing, you must be absolutely certain that you and/or your hired help do not copy and paste other's words and use them without attribution. This applies to all media you may use such as the firm website, any blogs, lawyer articles posted on the Web, the firm's newsletter, etc.
Also, if you are relying on someone else's article or blog post as source material (which is fine), you have to change enough of it to legitimately make it your own. I've heard varying percentages as to how much you need to change, but suffice to say that you can't change one or two words and assume that you've made it your own.
Bottom line - a plagiarism offense, whether intentional or not, can have serious negative ramifications for your practice. The Web is a wonderful tool for marketing your practice, but it can also serve to quickly damage a firm's reputation if the online community finds out that your firm has been pilfering other people's words.
Be vigilant, especially if you outsource your blogging, article writing or website content.